Beside a sun-dappled pond at the sublime Winvian Resort in Connecticut, Andrew (left) and Jeremy break the glass, one of several Jewish traditions they incorporated into the otherwise secular ceremony.

"Pooch of honor" Bosley sports a custom seersucker suit.

Andrew's mom carried a colorful bouquet with greenery, roses, and hydrangeas.

The ring bearer gets a little help with his boutonniere.

Guests watch as Jeremy and Andrew are wed.

Jeremy and Andrew after walking down the aisle together at the ceremony.

Andrew's family flanks the jubilant couple.

An antique toy car is placed at the entrance to the reception and filled with beautiful white flowers and greenery to greet guests.

Vintage-inspired place cards.

The pair couldn't resist campy golden cocktail napkins from MikWright; "We tend to seek a balance between the high and low," Jeremy says.

Each table had a different theme; perched atop the "music" table's orange shag carpet is a rack of 8-track tapes and a Woodstock LP tucked into a Fisher-Price record player. (Florist Candi Milliard rooted succulents in a retro cork planter and used craspedia to playfully suggest a disco ball.)

The happy couple takes a walk with their dog, Bosley.

The "photo" table holds vintage View-Master discs, slide carousels, wooden frames, and a classic camera; larkspur, peach roses, scabiosa seed heads, and craspedia shoot out of the centerpiece's wheatgrass base.

Another quirky centerpiece: This one is decorated with antique toy cars and license plates.

The couple cutting their tuxedo-themed cake.

Location and Catering: Winvian
Event Planning: Erica Kates of Ambiance Chic Wedding Designs
Flowers: Candi's Floral Creations
Cake: Sweet Maria's
Photography: Jaclyn Greenberg and Chris Brown of JAG Studios